Skip to content

Value model in AdditionalFieldDefinition is an empty class, thus silently drops all data #133

@ericqzeng

Description

@ericqzeng

The Value class in additionalfielddefinition.py is defined as an empty Pydantic BaseModel with no fields:

class Value(BaseModel):
  r"""Either a string or HypertextField. When OpenAPI Generator supports oneOf, we can semantically enforce this in the docs."""

Because the SDK's BaseModel uses the default Pydantic extra = 'ignore' behavior, any data passed to Value(...) is silently discarded. This means the value field on AdditionalFieldDefinition, which is typed as Optional[List[Value]], cannot actually carry any data.
Impact

This affects any consumer using AdditionalFieldDefinition through either:

  • EmployeeInfoDefinition.additional_fields
  • TeamInfoDefinition.additional_fields

When constructing an AdditionalFieldDefinition with values, the data in the value list is lost:

from glean.api_client.models.additionalfielddefinition import AdditionalFieldDefinition, Value
field = AdditionalFieldDefinition(
  key="languages",
  value=[Value(anchor="English"), Value(anchor="Spanish")]
)
print(field.model_dump())
# {'key': 'languages', 'value': [{}, {}]}
#                                 ^^   ^^  all data silently dropped

The same applies to HypertextField-style values:

Value(anchor="Glean", hyperlink="https://glean.com")
# Value()  — both anchor and hyperlink are silently ignored

This is the associated public docs page: https://developers.glean.com/api/indexing-api/bulk-index-employees. Note that even when passing in data to Value() as a dict, the whole dict object is ignored:

from glean.api_client.models.additionalfielddefinition import AdditionalFieldDefinition

raw = {"key": "username", "value": [{"username": "testuser"}]}
field = AdditionalFieldDefinition(**raw)
dumped = field.model_dump()
print(dumped)
# {'key': 'username', 'value': [{}]}

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No fields configured for Bug.

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions