Skip to content

MacAdmins python3, included modules and compatibility #87

@jelockwood

Description

@jelockwood

For quite sometime it was the case that whilst python3.10 was supported by MunkiReport-PHP, 3.11 was not.

See - https://www.kevinmcox.com/2023/06/munkireport-python-3-and-php-8/

As a result I stuck with 3.10 releases and had no problems. I do however now see the following on the MunkiReport-PHP wiki so will try and remember to setup a test install to see if this is still the case.

See - https://github.com/munkireport/munkireport-php/wiki/Python-updates

I would like to get more up to date so as to remove potential issues regarding the pending end of Rosetta support and resulting installation issues.

Another reason I stuck with 3.10 version was that I was able to confirm that as standard it had included all the Python modules I needed not only for MunkiReport-PHP but other projects like Okta Device Trust. Okta's own documentation at the time required running their scripts which required command line developer tools to be installed to download a build a python installation and download a build specific modules. It fortunately turned out that the pre-built MacAdmins 3.10 install had all those modules as standard.

Note: a simple way to determine what modules are installed is as follows.

  • Install python
  • Run the command /usr/local/bin/python3 -c "help('modules')" in Terminal.app - the path can be altered to test alternative installations of python but this path is the one used by the MacAdmins pkg

I have the following questions regarding the current status of the MacAdmins python pkg.

  1. Is the current installer for 3.14.5 a fully 'universal' pkg meaning it not only contains versions of Python that are native for both Apple Silicon and Intel Macs, but also that the installer itself is properly built to advertise this fact? See open issue Apple silicon releases think it's universal and require rosetta upon installation #85 It maybe this will turn out to not be pessary, I see that the plan is to drop Intel support in future releases and logically you will then not make it universal and not trigger this, An Autopkg munki recipe could then label newer releases as having only an Arm architecture and Munki will not try to install future updates on Intel but being the Installer pkg is labelled also as Arm only will not trigger any Rosetta issue.
  2. Does the current 3.14.5 pkg of Python have at least the same set of modules that 3.10 has/had?
  3. Would it be possible to get an additional module added (if not already included) to the next Python build? It could be helpful to have the Cyptography module included.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type
    No fields configured for issues without a type.

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions